7 Proven Methods to Accurately Measure Carbon Content in Steel

Have you ever wondered how the carbon content in metals is precisely measured? This article explores various methods, from infrared absorption to electrochemical analysis, shedding light on their principles and applications. By the end, you’ll understand the strengths and limitations of each technique, helping you appreciate the science behind metal quality control.

Determine Carbon Content in Steel

Table Of Contents

The development and use of metals and their composite materials often require precise control and accurate determination of their carbon and sulfur content.

Carbon in metal materials exists mainly in the form of free carbon, solid solution carbon, compound carbon, gaseous carbon, surface protection carburization, and coated organic carbon.

Currently, the methods for analyzing carbon content in metals include combustion, emission spectrometry, gas volumetric, non-aqueous titration, infrared absorption, and chromatography, among others.

However, each measurement method has a limited scope of application, and the measurement results can be impacted by various factors such as the form of carbon, whether it can be completely released during oxidation, and the blank value. Thus, the same method can produce different levels of accuracy in different situations.

This article summarizes the current analysis methods, sample preparation, instruments, and application fields for carbon analysis in metals.

1. Infrared absorption method

The combustion infrared absorption method, which is based on the infrared absorption method, is a specialized method for the quantitative analysis of carbon (and sulfur).

The principle behind this method involves burning the sample in an oxygen stream to produce CO2.

At a specific pressure, the energy absorbed by the CO2 from infrared rays is proportional to its concentration.

Therefore, the carbon content can be calculated by measuring the change in energy before and after the CO2 gas passes through the infrared absorber.

Principle of combustion-infrared absorption method

Principle of combustion-infrared absorption method

In recent years, infrared gas analysis technology has advanced rapidly, leading to the rapid emergence of various analytical instruments based on the principles of high-frequency induction heating, combustion, and infrared spectrum absorption.

When determining carbon and sulfur content using the high-frequency combustion infrared absorption method, the following factors should generally be taken into consideration: sample dryness, electromagnetic sensitivity, geometric size, sample size, type of flux, proportion, order of addition, amount of addition, blank value settings, etc.

This method has the advantage of providing accurate quantification with minimal interference.

It is suitable for users who place a high emphasis on the accuracy of carbon content and have sufficient time for testing during production.

2. Emission spectroscopy

When an element is energized by heat or electricity, it transitions from its ground state to an excited state, which will then spontaneously return to the ground state.

During the process of returning from the excited state to the ground state, each element releases its characteristic spectrum, and its content can be determined based on the intensity of this spectrum.

Principle of Emission Spectrometer

Principle of Emission Spectrometer

In the metallurgical industry, where production demands are high, it is necessary to quickly analyze the content of all major elements in the furnace water, not just carbon.

Spark direct reading emission spectrometers have become the preferred choice in this industry due to their ability to provide quick and stable results.

However, this method has specific requirements for sample preparation.

For instance, when analyzing cast iron samples using spark spectroscopy, it is necessary that the carbon on the surface of the sample be in the form of carbides, and free of graphite, otherwise, the analysis results may be affected.

Some users take advantage of the fast cooling and whitening properties of thin slices to determine the carbon content in castings by spark spectroscopy, after making the samples into slices.

When using spark spectroscopy to analyze carbon steel wire samples, the samples must be processed strictly, and placed either “upright” or “flat” on the spark table for analysis using a small sample analysis fixture, in order to improve the precision of the analysis.

3. Wavelength dispersive X-ray method

The Wavelength Dispersive X-ray Analyzer can quickly and simultaneously determine the content of multiple elements.

Principle of Wavelength Dispersive X-ray Fluorescence Spectrometer

Principle of Wavelength Dispersive X-ray Fluorescence Spectrometer

The wavelength dispersive X-ray fluorescence spectrometer (WDXRF) utilizes X-ray excitation to cause the inner electrons of the element atoms to transition in energy level and emit secondary X-rays, also known as X-ray fluorescence.

The spectrometer splits the light using a crystal, and the detector detects the diffracted characteristic X-ray signal.

By synchronizing and continuously changing the diffraction angle of the spectroscopic crystal and the controller, the characteristic X-ray wavelength and intensity of each wavelength X-ray produced by various elements in the sample can be obtained for qualitative and quantitative analysis.

First produced in the 1950s, WDXRF has been widely used in the geology department due to its ability to simultaneously determine multiple components in complex systems, leading to improved analysis speed.

However, the low fluorescence yield of light element carbon and significant absorption and attenuation of its characteristic radiation by heavy matrix materials such as steel present challenges in XRF analysis of carbon.

Repeated measurements of the ground surface may also result in increasing carbon content values. As a result, this method is not as widely used as the previous two methods mentioned.

4. Non-aqueous titration method

The non-aqueous titration method is a method of titration that uses a non-aqueous solvent. This method allows for the titration of weak acids and bases that cannot be titrated in an aqueous solution by selecting an appropriate solvent to increase their acidity or alkalinity.

For example, the weakly acidic carbonic acid generated by CO2 in water can be accurately titrated by using different organic reagents.

The commonly used non-aqueous titration method includes the following steps:

  1. The sample is burned at a high temperature in an electric arc furnace that is equipped with a carbon and sulfur analyzer.
  2. The carbon dioxide gas emitted from combustion is absorbed by the ethanol-ethanolamine solution and reacts with ethanolamine to form a relatively stable 2-hydroxyethylamine carboxylic acid.
  3. KOH is used for non-aqueous titration.

This method is toxic, long-term exposure can affect human health, and is difficult to operate, especially when the carbon content is high and the solution must be preset. Any carelessness can cause low results because of the escape of carbon.

Additionally, the reagents used in the non-aqueous titration method are mostly flammable products, and high-temperature heating operations are involved in the experiment, so the operators must have a strong awareness of safety.

5. Chromatography

The flame atomization detector is used in conjunction with gas chromatography to heat the sample in hydrogen and then detect the emitted gases, such as CH4 and CO, using the flame atomization detector-gas chromatography.

This method is ideal for those who have extremely low carbon content and high requirements for their test results. For instance, some users have used this method to test for trace amounts of carbon in high-purity iron, with a content of 4 µg/g and an analysis time of 50 minutes.

6. Electrochemical methods

Some users have introduced the use of potentiometric analysis to determine low carbon content in alloys.

After the iron sample is oxidized in an induction furnace, a potassium carbonate solid electrolyte-based electrochemical concentration cell is used to analyze and determine the gaseous product to determine the carbon concentration.

This method is especially suitable for the determination of very low concentrations of carbon. The accuracy and sensitivity of the analysis can be controlled by adjusting the composition of the reference gas and the oxidation rate of the sample.

However, this method has limited practical applications and remains mostly in the experimental research stage.

7. Online analysis method

When refining steel, it’s often necessary to monitor the carbon content of the molten steel in real-time in a vacuum furnace.

Some scholars in the metallurgical industry have introduced methods of using waste gas information to estimate the carbon concentration.

By using the oxygen consumption and concentration during the vacuum decarburization process, along with the flow rates of oxygen and argon, they estimate the carbon content in the molten steel.

Additionally, some users have developed methods and instruments for rapid determination of trace amounts of carbon in molten steel. By blowing a carrier gas into the molten steel, they estimate the carbon content by measuring the oxidized carbon in the carrier gas.

These online analysis methods are useful for quality management and performance control in the steel production process.

Don't forget, sharing is caring! : )
Shane
Author

Shane

Founder of MachineMFG

As the founder of MachineMFG, I have dedicated over a decade of my career to the metalworking industry. My extensive experience has allowed me to become an expert in the fields of sheet metal fabrication, machining, mechanical engineering, and machine tools for metals. I am constantly thinking, reading, and writing about these subjects, constantly striving to stay at the forefront of my field. Let my knowledge and expertise be an asset to your business.

Up Next

H Beam Sizes and Weight Chart

Have you ever wondered about the hidden world of H-beam steel? In this captivating article, we'll unravel the mysteries behind these essential construction components. Our expert mechanical engineer will guide…
MachineMFG
Take your business to the next level
Subscribe to our newsletter
The latest news, articles, and resources, sent to your inbox weekly.
© 2024. All rights reserved.

Contact Us

You will get our reply within 24 hours.