Laser Deep Penetration Welding: Things You Should Know

The process of laser welding, primarily for sheet metal welding, can be divided into two categories: fiber continuous laser welding and YAG pulse laser welding.

Based on the laser welding principle, it can be further divided into heat conduction welding and laser deep penetration welding. When the power density is less than 104 to 105 W/cm², it is considered heat conduction welding. This results in shallow penetration and a slower welding speed.

On the other hand, when the power density is greater than 105 to 107 W/cm², the metal surface will form “holes” due to heating and result in laser deep penetration welding. This method is characterized by its fast welding speed and large depth-to-width ratio.

The principle of heat conduction laser welding involves heating the surface to be processed through laser radiation, guiding the surface heat through transfer and internal diffusion, and melting the workpiece to form a specific molten pool by controlling laser parameters such as pulse width, energy, peak power, and repetition frequency. This method is suitable for thin plate welding.

Laser deep penetration welding is mainly used for gear welding and metallurgical sheet welding, and the focus of this article is on the principle of laser deep penetration welding.

Aluminum shell lithium battery top cover welding - fiber continuous laser (new energy vehicle cell, mostly 3-Series aluminum)

Aluminum shell lithium battery top cover welding – fiber continuous laser (new energy vehicle cell, mostly 3-Series aluminum)

1. Principle of Laser Deep Penetration Welding

Laser deep penetration welding typically uses an optical fiber continuous laser beam to join materials. The metallurgical process of this method is similar to electron beam welding and is accomplished through a “keyhole” structure.

When the material is exposed to a high power density laser, it evaporates and creates small holes. The small holes, filled with steam, behave like blackbodies and absorb almost all the energy from the incident beam.

The temperature inside the holes reaches approximately 2500 ℃ and heat is transferred from the outer walls of the high-temperature holes to melt the surrounding metal.

The small holes are filled with high-temperature steam that is generated by the continuous evaporation of the wall material under the laser’s irradiation. The four walls of the holes are surrounded by molten metal, and the liquid metal is surrounded by solid materials.

In most conventional welding processes and laser conduction welding, energy is first deposited on the surface of the workpiece and then transmitted to the interior through conduction.

The liquid flow and wall surface tension outside the hole walls are in dynamic equilibrium with the continuous steam pressure inside the hole cavity. The laser beam continuously enters the small holes and the material outside the holes is continuously flowing.

The movement of the laser beam keeps the small holes and the molten metal surrounding the holes in a stable state of flow.

This means that the small holes and molten metal will move forward with the speed of the leading beam, filling the gap left behind and solidifying to form the weld.

All these processes occur so quickly that the welding speed can easily reach several meters per minute.

6 series aluminum fiber CW laser welding (this is the high-speed rail floor)

6 series aluminum fiber CW laser welding (this is the high-speed rail floor)

2. Main Process Parameters of Laser Deep Penetration Welding

(1) Laser power

There is a threshold for laser energy density in laser welding. If the laser energy density is below this value, the penetration is shallow. However, if it reaches or exceeds this value, the penetration is greatly improved.

The generation of plasma, which signifies the progress of stable deep penetration welding, occurs only when the laser power density on the workpiece exceeds the threshold, which is dependent on the material.

When the laser power density is below the threshold, only surface melting of the workpiece takes place, resulting in stable heat conduction welding.

If the laser power density is near the critical condition for keyhole formation, the welding process becomes unstable, with alternating deep penetration welding and conduction welding, resulting in significant fluctuations in penetration depth.

During laser deep penetration welding, the laser power simultaneously controls the penetration depth and welding speed. The penetration depth is directly related to the beam power density and is a function of the incident beam power and beam focal spot.

In general, for a given diameter laser beam, the penetration increases as the beam power increases.

Kettle horse - YAG pulse laser welding (can directly make the appearance surface)

Kettle horse – YAG pulse laser welding (can directly make the appearance surface)

(2) Beam focal spot

The beam spot size is a critical variable in laser welding as it determines the power density. However, measuring the spot size for high-power lasers is a challenging task, despite the availability of various indirect measurement technologies.

See also  Handheld Laser Welder Heat Dissipation Technology: What to Know

The limit of the beam focus diffraction spot size can be calculated using light diffraction theory, but the actual spot size is larger due to the presence of focusing lens aberrations.

The simplest method of measurement is the equal temperature profile method, which involves measuring the focal spot and perforation diameter after burning thick paper and penetrating a polypropylene plate.

This method requires the mastery of laser power and the action time of the beam, which can be achieved through practice and measurement.

(3) Material absorption value

The laser absorption of materials is dependent on several important properties of the material, such as absorptivity, reflectivity, thermal conductivity, melting temperature, evaporation temperature, and so on.

There are two factors that affect the absorptivity of materials to the laser beam:

First, the resistance coefficient of the material. After measuring the absorptivity of the polished surface of the material, it has been found that the absorptivity of the material is directly proportional to the square root of the resistance coefficient, which changes with temperature.

Second, the surface state or finish of the material, which has a significant impact on the beam absorptivity and thus the welding effect.

Materials with high purity and general conductivity, such as stainless steel and nickel, are the best to weld.

On the other hand, high-conductivity materials like copper and aluminum are difficult to weld. Welding of 6 series aluminum and above is prone to cracks and pores.

The welding of copper generally depends on the application requirements, and it can be done with YAG pulse laser and fiber continuous laser.

In the jewelry industry, gold and silver are generally spot welded. However, there are few industrial applications for welding these materials. The focus here is on industrial applications.

The output wavelength of CO2 lasers is typically 10.6 μm. At room temperature, the absorption rate of non-metallic materials, such as ceramics, glass, rubber, and plastics, is very high, whereas the absorption rate of metal materials is poor.

However, once the material is melted or even vaporized, its absorption increases dramatically.

The method of surface coating or forming an oxide film on the surface is highly effective in improving the absorption of light beams.

(4) Welding speed

The welding speed has a significant impact on the penetration depth. Increasing the speed will result in shallower penetration, but a speed that is too low will cause excessive melting of the material and result in too much penetration of the workpiece.

Therefore, there is a suitable range of welding speeds for a specific material with a certain laser power and thickness, and the maximum penetration can be achieved at the corresponding speed value.

Stainless steel YGA pulse laser wire filling welding (it can overcome the problem of large butt joint and appearance surface treatment in the later stage)

Stainless steel YGA pulse laser wire filling welding (it can overcome the problem of large butt joint and appearance surface treatment in the later stage)

(5) Shielding gas

Inert gas is often used in laser welding to protect the molten pool. In some cases, protection may not be necessary if the material can be welded without surface oxidation.

However, most applications utilize helium, argon, nitrogen, or other gases to protect the workpiece from oxidation during welding.

Helium is an effective shielding gas due to its high ionization energy, which allows the laser beam to pass smoothly and reach the workpiece surface without any impediments. However, it is relatively expensive.

Argon is relatively cheap and has high density, providing good protection. But, it is prone to ionization by high-temperature metal plasma, which reduces the effective laser power and welding speed, as well as the penetration.

The surface of the weldment protected by argon is smoother compared to the surface protected by helium.

Nitrogen is the cheapest shielding gas, but it is not suitable for some types of stainless steel welding due to metallurgical problems, such as absorption, which can sometimes lead to pores in the lap area.

The second purpose of using shielding gas is to protect the focusing lens from metal vapor pollution and liquid droplet sputtering, which is especially important in high-power laser welding where the ejecta becomes more powerful.

The third function of the shielding gas is to disperse the plasma shielding produced by high-power laser welding. The metal vapor absorbs the laser beam, ionizing it into a plasma cloud, and the shielding gas around the metal vapor also ionizes due to heating.

If there is too much plasma, it will consume the laser beam to some extent. The plasma on the working surface acts as a second energy source, making the penetration shallower and the surface of the welding pool wider.

See also  Fiber Laser Welding vs. CO2 Laser Welding: Which is Better?

The recombination rate of electrons can be increased by increasing the collision of electrons with ions and neutral atoms, reducing the electron density in the plasma.

The lighter the neutral atom, the higher the collision frequency and the higher the recombination rate.

On the other hand, only shielding gas with high ionization energy will not increase the electron density due to its own ionization.

Atomic (molecular) weight and ionization energy of common gases and metals

Atomic (molecular) weight44028272456
Ionization energy (eV)24.4615.6814.55.967.617.83

As shown in the table, the size of the plasma cloud depends on the type of shielding gas used. Helium produces the smallest plasma cloud, nitrogen produces the second smallest, and argon produces the largest. The larger the plasma size, the shallower the penetration depth.

This difference is not only due to the different levels of gas molecule ionization, but also to the difference in metal vapor diffusion caused by the different densities of the shielding gas.

Helium has the lowest ionization and density, and it can quickly clear the rising metal vapor from the metal molten pool.

As a result, using helium as a shielding gas can effectively inhibit plasma and increase penetration and welding speed. Additionally, it is light and unlikely to cause pores.

However, in actual welding, using argon as a shield provides good results. The effect of plasma cloud on penetration is most noticeable at low welding speeds, and as the welding speed increases, its impact decreases.

The shielding gas is released onto the workpiece surface through a nozzle at a certain pressure. The shape of the nozzle and the outlet diameter are critical, as the nozzle must be large enough to cover the welding surface with the shielding gas, but it must also be limited in size to effectively protect the lens and prevent metal vapor pollution or metal splatter from damaging the lens.

The flow rate must also be controlled, otherwise, the laminar flow of the protective gas will become turbulent and air will be drawn into the molten pool, forming pores.

To improve the protective effect, lateral blowing can also be used, where the shielding gas is injected into the small hole of deep penetration welding at a certain angle through a small diameter nozzle.

This not only reduces the plasma cloud on the workpiece surface, but also affects the plasma in the hole and the formation of small holes, resulting in increased penetration depth and an ideal weld with a high depth-width ratio.

However, this method requires precise control of the size and direction of the gas flow, as turbulence and damage to the molten pool can easily occur, making it difficult to stabilize the welding process.

(6) Lens focal length

The laser beam is usually focused during welding and a lens with a focal length of 63mm to 254mm (2.5″ to 10″) is typically selected. The spot size of the focus is directly proportional to the focal length; a shorter focal length results in a smaller spot.

However, the focal length also affects the focal depth, which increases with the focal length. This means that a short focal length improves the power density but requires accurate maintenance of the distance between the lens and the workpiece for proper penetration.

In actual welding, the shortest focal depth used is usually 126mm (5″). When a larger joint or increased welding is needed, a lens with a focal length of 254mm (10″) can be selected, but this requires a higher laser output power for the desired deep penetration keyhole effect.

For laser powers exceeding 2kW, especially for 10.6μm CO2 lasers, the reflection focusing method is often used, with polished copper mirrors as the mirrors, to avoid the risk of optical damage to the focusing lens.

Copper mirrors are often recommended for high-power laser beam focusing due to effective cooling.

(7) Focus position

In laser welding, the position of the focus is crucial to ensure adequate power density. The variation in the relative position between the focus and the workpiece surface significantly impacts the depth and width of the weld.

In most laser welding applications, the focus is usually set about a quarter of the required penetration below the surface of the workpiece.

(8) Laser beam position

The final quality of the weld when laser welding different materials is largely controlled by the laser beam position, with butt joints being more sensitive than lap joints.

See also  Welding Copper with Laser: High Brightness Fiber Laser Solution

For instance, when welding a quenched steel gear to a low-carbon steel drum, proper control of the laser beam position will result in a weld mainly composed of low-carbon components, which possess excellent crack resistance.

In certain situations, the geometry of the workpiece being welded necessitates a deflection angle for the laser beam. When the angle of deflection between the beam axis and the joint plane is less than 100 degrees, the absorption of laser energy by the workpiece remains unaffected.

(9) Control of gradual increase and decrease of laser power at welding start and end points

In laser deep penetration welding, small holes are present regardless of the depth of the weld. When the welding process is completed and the power switch is turned off, pits will appear at the end of the weld.

Furthermore, if the new laser welding layer covers the previous weld, excessive absorption of the laser beam may occur, leading to overheating or porosity in the weldment.

To prevent these issues, the power start and end points can be programmed to allow for adjustable start and end times. This is accomplished by electronically increasing the starting power from zero to the set power value quickly and adjusting the welding time.

Finally, the power is gradually decreased from the set value to zero at the end of welding.

Stainless steel optical fiber continuous laser welding (suitable for butt welding of small plates with a thickness of 0.2-3mm)

Stainless steel optical fiber continuous laser welding (suitable for butt welding of small plates with a thickness of 0.2-3mm)

3. Characteristics, Advantages and Disadvantages of Laser Deep Penetration Welding

(1) Characteristics of laser deep penetration welding

  1. High Aspect Ratio Welding

The high aspect ratio welding process is characterized by deep and narrow welds, which are formed by directing a cylindrical high-temperature vapor cavity around the workpiece. This results in the molten metal being formed around the cavity and extending to the workpiece.

  1. Minimum Heat Input

The welding process requires a minimum heat input due to the high temperature within the small hole. This results in a fast melting process and a low input heat on the workpiece, leading to minimal thermal deformation and a small heat-affected zone.

  1. High Density Welds

The high-temperature steam within the small hole promotes stirring of the welding pool and the escape of gas, resulting in a dense and penetration weld without pores. The fast cooling rate after welding helps refine the weld structure.

  1. Strong Welds

The welding process does not require electrodes or filler wires, and the heat source is hot, leading to a reduction in impurity content and a change in the inclusion size and distribution in the molten pool. This results in a strong and tough weld that is at least equal to or even stronger than the parent metal.

  1. Precise Control

The small focus spot of the laser allows for high accuracy in positioning the weld. The laser output has no “inertia” and can be stopped and restarted quickly, making it ideal for welding complex workpieces with NC beam movement technology.

  1. Non-Contact Atmosphere Welding

The non-contact atmosphere welding process involves a photon beam that delivers energy to the workpiece without any physical contact. This means that no external forces are applied to the workpiece, and the laser is not affected by magnetism or air.

(2) Advantages of laser deep penetration welding

  1. High Welding Speed and Minimal Deformation

The focused laser used in laser welding has a much higher power density compared to conventional methods, allowing for fast welding speeds and minimal heat-affected zones and deformation. This makes it possible to weld even difficult materials like titanium.

  1. Efficient and Low Maintenance

The beam is easy to transmit and control, leading to less frequent replacement of the welding gun and nozzle, and no vacuum pumping is required for electron beam welding. This significantly reduces the auxiliary downtime and increases the load factor and production efficiency.

  1. High Strength and Toughness

The purification and high cooling rate during laser welding result in high strength, toughness, and comprehensive properties of the weld.

  1. Cost-Effective

The low average heat input and high machining accuracy of laser welding help reduce the cost of reprocessing. In addition, the low operating cost of laser welding also helps reduce the overall processing cost of the workpiece.

  1. Easy to Automate

Laser welding allows for effective control of beam intensity and fine positioning, making it easy to automate the welding process.

(3) Disadvantages of laser deep penetration welding

  • Limited Welding Depth
  • Stringent Requirements for Workpiece Assembly
  • Significant Initial Investment in Laser System

Get Expert Advice

Any questions? Let our experts help you

About The Author

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Scroll to Top